PMMS LogoPMMS
Lion Roar
U.S.Navy PT Boat
Lion Roar 1:35 Super Detail Set #LAS35003
Preview by Terry Ashley

Italeri
Introduction:
There have been a number of update sets released for the recent Dragon M2/M2A1 Half-track (kit #6329) mostly in the form of wheels sets to address that issue in the kit plus some storage sets and markings as well as the basic update set from Lion Roar (set #LE35078) release recently .

We now have some more extensive sets being released such as these from Tank Workshop in resin and Voyager Models in etched metal but the most extensive without doubt is this new set from Lion Roar which virtually replaces the entire kit apart from the chassis, suspension/wheels, front fenders and some accessories like the radios with etched and resin parts.

When first seeing the publicity shots of the built up set the emphasis seemed to be on the main body panels being replaced with etched metal drawing comments of overkill and unnecessary, but there is much more to this set than just the body panels as we will see.

The Update Set:

The set consists of 11 large etched frets (145mm x 85mm) and 2 smaller frets (110mm x 65mm) and these are in different thicknesses with thicker metal for the body panels and other larger details and thinner sheets for things like the storage boxes and smaller details and this variation in thickness gives good definition to the parts when assembled.

Also included are;

The standard of etching is again excellent with good relief where needed and clean crisp etching on parts with finer details plus many very small parts that will require care and soldering would be the best method of assembly for the larger components.

The resin parts are cleanly cast with just very small casting blocks to be removed but there were a couple of small air holes present with the overall detail being very crisp and well defined especially on the engine parts.

Obviously with the set of this size and complexity some experience working with etched parts would seem essential as would having a good etched bending tool and soldering facilities handy.

Of the 13 etched frets, 1 is for barbed wire leaving 12 frets for the model details and of these 3 are devoted entirely to the body panels and another 2 have some body structure parts which leaves about 70% of the set parts for the smaller details and these can just as easily be used to detail up the Dragon kit like a “normal” detail set if you don’t want to use the metal body panels.

But using the resin and etched parts on the existing kit body parts will require a fair bit of surgery to remove things like the moulded on rear compartment seats and other details so there is a lot of work required whichever rout you choose.

Front body and Cab:

Assembly starts here and the floor section has a number of bends in different directions requiring care as its easy to get ‘trapped’ when bending these and the fitting of the firewall is a rather tricky as there are no actual locating points and it just “sits” on the front of the floor pan till soldered in place and will test your patience and skills early on.

Added to the floor are separate tread plate sections plus the Driver’s foot pedals and some of the gear levers plus the front radiator louver operating lever, there is also a new resin gear shift to replace the larger of the kit levers but this unfortunately misses the ‘extra’ bend on this just as the kit lever does.

The two crew seats have 3 part etched bases with resin cushions that have excellent detail and you use the modified kit backrests to finish the seats.

The cab side panels have inner bolted trips added and these must be fitted correctly as they form the only means of lining up the sides with the floor and bulkhead and its important to get these all lined up correctly as any small miss-alignment here will be magnified as you progress with the assembly.

The outer body panels have the panel lines engraved and the many attachment screws etched in place including the screw head slot but as is the want of etched parts these are also flat and lack the domed shape of the actual screws as opposed to the kit screws which have the dome shape but not the screw slot.

The windscreen frame is next and again some nifty bending is required which is complicated due to the bevelled side sections which overlap the edges when you put the part into your bending tool and care is needed.

Added to this is the clear windscreen sheet trapped between two etched screen frames and again you have to take care not to mar the clear sheet when using the cyanoacrylate as soldering here will just melt the sheet. There are also separate windscreen wipers and on the inside some small wing nut fittings to finish off.

Fitting the screen to the assembled cab sides will see you having to make sure everything is lined up correctly as the only attachment guides is the fit of the previous side panel/firewall join which again highlights the need to get this right at the start, sorry if that sounds repetitive but this is important.

The outer armoured windscreen shield is a separate part with workable hinges and the armoured vision port covers also slide within their attachment brackets allowing these to be positioned open or closed as required and the three support posts when the shield is open are from thin plastic rod and small etched brackets.

On the inside is added the instrument panel which has the outer panel in etched with excellent relief details and the dials are on the supplied decal that fits behind the etched panel and attached to the kit panel after shaving off the raised detail.

Instrument panel
Lion Roar

The front radiator panel is made up of numerous parts with each louver as a separate part allowing these to be positioned at any angle but again some careful bending is required and the fitting of this to the body sides will depend on how straight these were assembled earlier.

Also at the front are new etched bumper mountings and the bumpers for both the front roller and the winch style bumper with just the front curved section of the winch bumper (parts C18, C17) and the roller from the kit used with all other parts in etched metal. For the roller side mountings you have to make the small springs from the thin wire provided and this is easily done by winding the wire around a drill bit shaft to get the required length spring.

The engine hood panels are next and these have the central T panel with the four hood doors separate with small three part hinges that can be made workable so the hood folds up like the real thing. Care will be needed making the hinges as they are very small and you have to ensure all three on each join are attached evenly and tightly so there are no spaces between the hood panels.

If your elected to use these doors on the Dragon kit after cutting out the plastic hood doors the etched doors are the exact same size and the kit doors and fit the plastic T section perfectly but you will have to add thin plastic sills inside the door cut-outs for the doors to sit properly once attached.

The hood T securing clips are made up of three very small etched parts attached to thin plastic rod and while fiddly look quite convincing and again could be used on the Dragon kit itself.

If you show the engine bay doors open there is a new resin engine to replace the plastic kit item and this is superbly cast with excellent detail definition as well as being more complete with accessories such as the Distributor, Fuel and Vacuum Pump and Oil Filler Pipe included which are all missing from the Dragon engine.

The only thing to be added is the spark plug and other wiring and the braided copper wire supplied is use for this by using the individual wire strands for the wiring.

The front radiator fans are in two flat etched parts you sandwich together but you have the add the curve in the blades and slightly twist these for a better look while the two fan belts are also in etched strips and these should be annealed by running through a candle flame so they can be better curved around the belt pulleys.

Assembled Engine
Lion RoarLion Roar

To add this to the kit lower engine sump pan you have to cut off the thin locating ridge for the kit engine and just glue the resin engine in place with the lower cross member support a perfect fit into the same chassis locating ridges used by the kit part A36 so fitting is very easy.

Added further back are the side crew doors and these again have the screws depicted with the screw slot but flat profile and have the upper folding ‘window’ as a separate part with the main door hinges and top window hinges that again can be made workable so you can position the doors open or closed as you wish.

Additional detail for the doors include the door handles, inner latch made up of 5 parts, a number of small added bolt heads, separate map case that is used on the early M2 and for the top window is the sliding armoured cover for the vision port which actually slides inside the two mounting plates again allowing this to be positioned open or closed as you wish.

Other parts for the cab assembly are the three part side steps and a few reinforcing bolted strips more for the detail than actually securing the parts together while on the right side is the larger ‘box’ under the door made up of 6 etched parts and you add the kit fenders which have to be cut from the kit body pan which is easy enough as well as the axe, shovel and pick brackets and tie downs provided to add to the kit tools.

Added to the fenders are the etched head light bush guards for either the M2 and M2A1 style and resin rolled tarps stowed here with these being nicely textured including etched tie downs and securing straps for a good appearance.

While here I will mention that there are 120 very small tie down cleats provided to add around the bodywork as required and these have embossed detail including the rounded attachment points instead of just being plain flat metal. You are also provided with a metal ‘jig’ to bend these to the required shape before fitting to the model and give a very good appearance. There are also 180 small bolt heads to also use as required about the model to add additional detail.

Rear Body:

There are different body panels for both the M2 and M2A1 so take care to use the right ones depending on the version you are building as well as two completely different setups for the weapons rings of the M2 with the full skate ring and the M2A1 with the forward pedestal mounting and the instructions are divided into separate sections for each.

These are thankfully nearly all flat panels not requiring much bending apart from the lower floor section which is made up of five large parts that have some easy and complex bends required and you will have to carefully plan the bending order to avoid getting trapped with nowhere to go on a couple of these and again fitting the segments together will need care to ensure everything is lined up correctly before adding the upper compartment walls. The locker doors in the floor are all separate parts with nice tread plate pattern and more of those workable hinges allowing them to be opened as well as other tread plate panels for the floor.

The large side walls again have the slotted screws with a flat profile and with additional internal frame bracing sections to add detail and also to form the outer frames for the two side storage lockers. The outer edges of these inner frames have to bend at right angles to act as the locating lips when fitting to the bottom body pan but the instructions don’t actually say to do this and it was only when working out how to fit the side walls in place did this become known, so take note.

The doors for the storage lockers have workable hinges and top latches with fine chain for the pin while the inside lockers are etched boxes with the different size boxes for the M2 or M2A1 provided as well as the radio box that uses the kit radio and at the back the fuel tanks are also made up of 6 etched parts that will require careful bending for the tank curve and using the kit tanks as a guide would be helpful.

Additional detail is the long rod grab rails along the front of the bench seats as well as the seat cushions in resin with very nice cushion texture included plus on the outside about 30 of the small tie down cleats to be added.

The most notable inclusion at the back is the large storage racks used on the M2A2 which are missing from the Dragon kit and these are quite complex assemblies with the upper and lower frame separate as are the 4 slats inside each frame and the two frames can be assembled so they fold up adding a bit of choice for the final configuration.

Assembled Rear stowage rack
Lion Roar

The support arms when the racks are lowered have small rod pins that allow the arms to be slipped on and off depending if the final position and you are provided with resin bedrolls with excellent definition as well as etched securing straps and more of the fine tie down cleats to attach these too.

Weapons Rings:

The M2 ring uses the Dragon kit skate ring (part K24) as the basis and you have to trim off the outer frame leaving just the upright skate ring to which is added a new etched outer frame and 20 small fillets and mounting brackets, these are finer than the kit parts but requires a fair bit of work.

For the M2A1 there is an additional lip around the top of the body panels that requires careful bending and the pedestal mount uses the inner ring only from kit part C17 with the other parts in etched metal and getting the subtle curves of the pedestal walls can best be done using the kit part as a guide.

Additional items for the body sides is the jerry can rack in front of the doors which has the body mount and the actual jerry can mount rack with etched retaining strap which requires you to use the kit jerry cans after trimming off the plastic strap.

Along the rear sides are the mine racks from three etched parts and resin mines to fill the racks or you can stow other equipment as required based on photos of the vehicle you are building.

Added at the back are the two steps and taillight “boxes” made up of 5 etched parts each with additional etched bolt heads with the kit tail lights being used along with etched tie downs for the kit machine gun ground tripods stowed on the rear hull and steps.

The weapons:
Assembling the Boat itself is probably the easiest part with the large assortment of weapons provided really lifting the model to a new level.

Torpedos:
The four lightweight Mk.XIII torpedos are in two halves each with engraved surface details and open nose hook with the fit being very good leaving just a small join seam easily sanded smooth. The small twin screws are nicely done but there is a bit of cleanup needed on these with the four fins provided in etched brass for simple but nice looking torpedos.

The roll off racks are nicely moulded with very small attachment cable eyes and wing nuts with the torpedos attached with the fine wire provided with these mounted on simple deck racks.

Italeri

5” Rocket Launchers:
The later Elco Boats had two eight-tube 5” Rocket Launchers mounted either side of the foredeck and these are made up of two racks of four tubes moulded in the usual halves which have additional etched parts for the mountings. There are a couple of pin marks on the mounting posts to deal with but the fit overall is good and the racks can be positioned in the stowed or firing positions as required.

The rocket storage boxes are also provide and the lids can be shown open or closed with 12 rockets included in the box moulding to show if open.

Twin Browning .50cal:
There are two hydraulically powered twin .50cal MG turrets fore and aft with each in two parts that fit neatly together and the thin guard rail added to the front. The rear backrest of the turret has a fairly large mould seam to be removed but other than that there is no other cleanup required.

The MGs themselves are superbly moulded with excellent received details which are actually some of the better plastic .50cals you will see and have the aircraft type perforated barrel cooling jackets. The cooling holes may be a little oversized and the muzzles could be drilled but the overall effect is very good.

The cocking handles are rather basic but the thumb firing levers are included at the back and the two are joined by a large pin on one and the locating hole on the other, there is also a sizable pin mark on the inside of one gun but this is hidden when they are fitted together.

Added to the guns is the lower mounting ‘tray’ and nicely moulded .50cal ammo belts which you need to carefully bend to shape and the guns can be fitted to the central mount so they can elevate as well as the turret traverse.

Added to the turrets are very intricate ‘cages’ with very thinly moulded railings that again will require care removing the mould seams but again have a good scale feel to them.

Italeri kit parts
Italeri
Lion Roar update parts
Lion Roar
Lion Roar

20mm Oerlikon gun:
The gun is moulded in one piece with excellent details and just the mould seam to be removed but the muzzle could do with being drilled out for a better look and the distinctive ammo drum is superbly moulded with crisp details. There are four magazines provided, one for the gun and three for storage and these are in two parts each with the magazine and one end section separate for good definition but there is a minor sink mark on a couple of the magazines which should be easy to fill.

The gun is mounted on a simply pintle mount with separate legs that fit into the deck mounting plate and its best to fit the legs pins to the mounting plate at the same time as gluing them to the mounting (part 4F) to ensure everything lines up correctly.

An ammo storage locker is provided which has etched latches and this is positioned on the deck behind the gun with the three additional ammo drums positioned on top of the locker. 

Italeri kit parts
Italeri
Modified kit magazine to take the updated parts
Lion Roar
Fully assembled gun
Lion Roar

37mm M9 gun:
The Oldsmobile 37mm M9 Automatic Cannon from the P39 Airacobra fighter plane with a distinctive curved 30 round magazine and mounted on a simply deck mounting plate on the foredeck and was especially useful against surface target such as Japanese barges.

The kit gun is in two halves and the large curved magazine as a separate part with a choice of plastic or metal barrels plus the rear firing handles for a fairly simple assembly. There is again a large moulding seam on the inside of the magazine to be removed while the seam line over the moulded on 37mm rounds is along the shell casing/round join and can be left to better simulate this join just being trimmed from between the rounds.

Added to the magazine are two etched frames and four cross members that add considerably to the final appearance but you must ensure the two frames are positioned evenly or the cross members will not sit correctly.

The simply ‘U’ pintle mount fits tightly to the gun which is good as the gun doesn’t flop about and this mounting is held to the lower mounting by an inner washer that allows the gun to rotate as well as elevate in the upper mounting.

Click for larger views
Lion Roar
Close new window to return to review

40mm Bofors gun:
In some ways this is the centre piece of the model especially from an armour modeller’s viewpoint and is an extremely detailed assembly with the gun and an elaborate mounting base and deck mounting plate.

The gun has the large receiver in two conventional halves with very good details included that match photos well including the lower toothed elevation bracket with again nice details included. There is a separate cocking handle and rear bracket and the good fit of the gun halves means the resulting join seam is very easy to deal with once the glue has dried but the upper ammo clip guides are a little thick and could do with careful thinning for a better appearance. 

There is also a choice of plastic barrel with separate flash suppressor or one piece turned aluminium barrel with flash suppressor included and the choice is very easy really.

The gun has the two lower equilibrator cylinders are in two halves with separate end caps and again the fit is good making cleanup of the join seam easy along with separate piston arms. If you do not glue the pistons to the cylinders or the elevation bracket when the gun is trapped between the two gun mountings (parts 16F and 34F) then the gun will elevate after assembly. You are provided with three 4 round ammo clips but photos show the clips mounted in the gun have 5 rounds while those on the rear ammo racks have the 4 rounds as depicted?

Added to the gun is the upper sight frame with the four circular sights provide as etched parts for a finer appearance than could be obtained from plastic parts and added to the gun mountings are the left side elevation hand winder.

The large mounting base has numerous parts including the central mounting guides, the two ‘gunner’s’ seats with the small cut-outs included as well as the lower and rear mounting frames that again will require care in removing the moulding seams but a quite thin in overall appearance.

The gun mounting is attached to the large deck plate with an underside securing disc to allow the whole mounting to rotate for quite an impressive assembly.

There are some smaller details that can be added as with any kit with the reference images showing these if you wish to add the finer details to further improve the gun assembly.

Click for larger views
Lion Roar
Close new window to return to review

 

There are a few additional resin packs with etched straps to use as required to finish as well as the large fret of barbed wire which can be rolled up and added as storage as this is often seen stowed on the front radiator cover.

Instructions:

The 14 page instruction sheet has exploded view drawings showing the assemble steps but due to the complexity of some assembles care is needed and careful study of the instruction essential.

When bending some of the more complex pieces getting the bend order right will reduce frustration but this is not always easy and using a good etched bending tool will certainly help and again I used the original Etch Mate for bending the parts during this review.

Conclusion:

This is a massive update set and one thing is for sure, it is not for the inexperienced modeller and an engineering degree wouldn’t go astray if you use the full set of body panels to basically rebuild the Dragon kit.

As mentioned above about 30% of the parts are used for the body panels leaving the remainder to make up the many detail updates such as the detailed engine, driver’s cab interior, front radiator louvered cover and hinged engine compartment doors and most importantly the rear storage racks with the excellent .50cal added for good measure.

And while the full body rebuild may be too daunting for many the set still has plenty to offer with the numerous other details to use as an extensive detail set for the Dragon kit proper.

Adding the many individual detail updates in the set will require no more skills than would be needed for any other detail set of this type and it’s only if you want to tackle the full body rebuild will you see the additional skills needed come into play.

There is one detail conspicuous by its absence and that is the exhaust pipe support bracket for the right bogie unit which is surprising and this is left to you to make possibly from left over etched fret framing?

I found a lot of very useful items in this set even without the full body panels but there will be some alterations required on the Dragon kit parts to use these as a “normal” update sets but will add considerable detail to the kit whichever way you decide to go and will certaining provide a challenge if you go for the full body.

Highly recommended for more experienced modellers 8/10

Etched and other parts

Click on thumbnails for larger view
Lion RoarLion Roar
Close new window to return to review

Thanks to Lion Roar for the review set.



Page created April 12, 2007